A discourse on theories of fnaf 1-4 in general by Mod Cupcake
Part 1: The box
Scott said he will not open the box. We need to work out why he said that, and if he means it as in he is not going to be responsible for finding a way to open/actively opening it for us, or if he means it in the sense of opening it will never happen.
The box is introduced at the end of night 6, saying that ‘some things are best left forgotten, for now’. This can mean different things: the box is a red herring, the box is not important, the meaning of the box has not been realised, or it could be because it may become important later on, possibly through a hint that may be dropped in the Halloween update.
Or it could be because we have not been approaching opening it properly, or we have no reason to open it, as the clues may be right under our nose.
Like the Joker said in Arkham City, ‘How do you keep a secret from the World’s Greatest Detective? You hide it right under his pointy little nose, and wait.’So I think that the box requires a different angle of approach. Maybe we need to unlock it like the process to unlock the 8th night. Maybe we need to think outside (or inside) the box to work out what is inside it, without opening it.
But I think that clicking on locks to make them swing is not how you open it. We need a key, like with any other lock. We may not need to worry about the box, we need to worry about the key.
-mod cupcake
P.S. I may post more of my theories later on. If anyone has any questions, send me a question on my main blog, www.the-fuck-is-a-blog.tumblr.com
TL;DR Stop clicking the locks on the fnaf 4 box, find a key for those locks.